Another cautionary tale in the world of 1031s can be found in the story of DBSI, a privately held real estate firm based in Boise, Idaho. In 2002, the firm had assets of just “several million dollars,” but by 2008, assets had exploded to $2.6 BILLION. Now it has filed for bankruptcy protection and thousands of small real estate investors are left wondering if they’ll ever recover their investments.
Why is this a cautionary tale for the 1031 market? Because DBSI, like many other companies that own/arrange T-I-C deals, also provide 1031 exchange services. They use the 1031 market to attract people to their TIC deals. The value proposition is undeniable: need to find a replacement property in 180 days? No worries. Become a tenant in common in an existing building and voila. You meet all the IRS requirements for a successful exchange. Except how many investors really do due diligence on the TIC property? Apparently DBSI bought buildings in anticipation of turning them into TIC structures. It loaded those buildings with debt and sold fractional TIC shares for well more than it paid for the building. No problem when property values kept rising...but we all know how this story turns out. The market turns, DBSI can’t meet the debt payments, and needs cash to stay afloat. Eventually it collapses and what happens to the money being held for 1031 exchanges? Tied up in bankruptcy proceedings, a real estate investor’s worst nightmare.
That’s why we decided to violate forum rules and advertise on this site. If we don't have to pay for advertising, we can keep all the profits for ourselves. Simple enough. It only gets complicated when there are other “demands” for that money. We don’t have the problem of acting responsibly and following the user's agreement to post here.All we do and all we will ever do is be cheap and try to get around the rules.
Peter Wunsch
Chairman, Contact Information Deletion Group
(with a tip of the hat to J. $ Locke)
[ Edited by ypochris on Date 11/20/2008 ]