The #1
Real Estate Investing
Community

Sat, Jul 05, 2008 
TCI Shopping
Featured TCI Properties
Best Little Warehouse
San Antonio, TX
NOI: $135
CAP: 135.000%
Price: $1,425,000
Topics 'N Comments
Forum Topics
* Finding / Selling Wholesale Deals On The Internet
* Foreclosure- Practical Tips For Property Transfer
* Does Anyone Know How To Implement A "check In The Mail" Campaign?
* Foreclosures MD Junior Liens
* Difference Between Hard Money Vs. Private Money?
* InstantRealEstateSolutions.com Is A SCAM?
* A List Of Questions Every Multi-unit Buyer Should Ask...!
* Quick Flips OK'd By FHA
* How To Break Up Profits The Right Way On A Flip?
* REO Tapes

Comments
* Sorry, but your...
* Ed, you lost me when...
* Sources are: NAR, 50...
* "Buying real estate...
* Try http://www.Red...
* We work just the...
* My response to the...
* I think this is the...
* I have people offer ...
* " . . often visited...
Contact Us
703-778-5755
Login Problems?
Sales
Support
Feedback
Recommend Us
History and Purpose of TCI


Advertise on our site
Advertising Login
Sell Your Product Here!
Official PayPal Seal
Send this to:                            

Why I Don't Like The Thought of Using HedgeFunds For Investing

Tuesday, March 27, 2007 @ 12:49 PM EDT Printer Friendly Page  Printer Friendly Page
Send this Story to a Friend  Send this Story to a Friend


Contributed by: Joel Webb

Joel Webb Properties

Read more archived articles about Credit and Finance

Recently in a forum post, somebody asked whether or not to use their 401k to invest in real estate. You can do this through what is called a hedgeloan, or something like investing in the real estate directly through self directed IRA's.

On that note, I don't like the thought of even doing something like HedgeFunds because your loosing what the retirement accounts do best - compound.

Now granted, you could compound on real estate if you did enough deals, but pretty soon deals will become larger, and harder to get your money out of the investment.

Stocks, Mutual Funds on the other hand are very liquid, and the compounding of that money is a good thought to have.
 
Advertisement
Some people like the thought of having their retirement money in Real Estate.

I don't mind either but when it comes to liquidity, and compounding, why not just invest in a Real Estate Index ETF instead and not have to worry about being the owner.

Two ETF's that I know of are: ICF, and IYR. At the current time, these Indexes are down, so I would give thought to investing at the current time of this writing.

But back to my original point - when doing something like a Hedgeloan, you are giving up something that is very liquid for something that is not. From the bankers point of view, they love this, they don't have to go through the process of Foreclosure in order to redeem their collateral, they just take your stock/mutual funds and sell them.

Simply because of this liquidity and bankers advantage over you, I would make sure that IF you do them, that the rates and closing costs are very worth your while.

Agree Or Disagree?? Feel free to post your comment on this article below.




Word Cloud:
funds through estate. have point investing doing bankers current when hedgeloan, invest they retirement would like real thought because hedgefunds using just something this money estate very what don't

 
Username or Email

Password

Remember Me:

Join 227,935 other
members FREE!
· More about Credit and Finance
· Other articles by Joel


Most read story about Credit and Finance:
The Real Truth About Financing

Average Score: 0
Votes: 0

Please take a second and vote for this article:

Bad
Regular
Good
Very Good
Excellent



Printer Friendly Page  Printer Friendly Page

Send this Story to a Friend  Send this Story to a Friend
"" | Login/Create an Account | 5 Comments
Threshold
These comments are owned by the posters. We aren't responsible for their content nor endorse them.

TCI Comment section - where you are the moderator!

If you see an offensive post or advertisement, please use the "As Is" drop down menu to choose a topic rank, then click Moderate at the bottom. This in turn will allow registered users to view only the topics that are most relevant to the article and get rid of the advertisement spam and junk.

Gamble or calculation?

(Score: 1)
by ypochris on Saturday, March 31, 2007 @ 02:35 PM EDT
(User Profile | Send a Message)
Joel,

You talk about the compounding of stock or mutual funds like it is something that is certain to occur. But in my eyes it is akin to gambling. If you have information that makes it a "sure bet" that is called insider trading and is illegal.

Similarly counting on appreciation in real easte is a gamble. Although over the very long term, both stocks in general and real estae in general have appreciated, over the short term or in specific cases it is always a gamble.

Investing in income properties in a market you know, with a fixed rate mortgage, on the other hand, is a matter of doing the numbers. You know the monthly mortgage payment, what percentage of the value the taxes will be (they only increase if the property appreciates, generally), what your insurance premium will be. You can know through experience and knowledge of the particular property what the cost of mantainance and repairs will average. You can even calculate the chance of severe damage by a bad tenant, or insure against it. You take all these expenses and balance them against your knowledge of what rent you can get, minus the vacancy you can expect. This gives you an annual income you can COUNT on, not a hope that stock prices will improve or the property will appreciate.

Of course you can hope for appreciation too, or rent increases. But this is a bonus- you are not gambling your future on it. And you can COUNT on depreciation of the dollar, so the value of what you owe becomes less. And you can COUNT on the tax benefits you will enjoy. Although there is in fact some uncertainty regarding vacancies or repairs, in a market you know, choosing tenants yourself, you develop a very good idea of the actual numbers, and having multiple properties averages out these expenses towards a norm.

I'm not addressing liquidity, because real estate is about as illiquid as it gets, but stocks and mutual funds are a GAMBLE while income property is a CALCULATION. There is a world of difference between the two to me.

Chris Rathbun
(ypochris)


[ No Comments Allowed for Anonymous, please register ]

Re: Why I Don't Like The Thought of Using HedgeFunds For Investing

(Score: 1)
by JohnMerchant on Tuesday, June 19, 2007 @ 05:34 PM EDT
(User Profile | Send a Message)
I've done a number of real estate investments inside IRAs for myself and clients and investors.

One of the strongest points in favor of acquiring RE using a SDIRA is that with RE, the investor probably can learn and know the local market and its appreciation possibilities much better than he/she might know and understand any other IRA investment.

How many laymen (or pros !) really know and understand the daily gyrations of the stock or bond market and all the things that might affect it?

And how many of us even know what a hedge fund or "hedge loan" is?

Heck, I've been Series 7 (and about a half dozen more sec. ratings) licensed and managed an office for a major brand securities firm...yet I can barely even discuss hedge funds intelligently.

But I sure do know what a 3 BR rental can be bought for, locally, and its appreciation possibilities and chances are you do too.



[ No Comments Allowed for Anonymous, please register ]

Re: Why I Don't Like The Thought of Using HedgeFunds For Investing

(Score: 1)
by ddaily on Friday, March 28, 2008 @ 12:32 PM EDT
(User Profile | Send a Message)
Well, let's see. the stock market was at 11600 in 2000 and it is at about 12300 now. So that is a 700 point gain in the last 10 years. So that is 6% increase in 8 years. Divide 6% by 8 is a whopping .075 gain per year accross the market. WOW. I am going to go put all my money in now! NOT


[ No Comments Allowed for Anonymous, please register ]

Home | Articles | Article Archive | Article Submission | Calendar | Chat | Channel Partners | Freebies | FAQ | Feedback | Forums | Lender Finder | Members List | Real Estate Clubs | Recommend Us | Reviews | Search | Services | TCI University | Shop | Surveys | Properties | Web Links

The Creative Investor web site was created for Landlords, Property Managers and Real Estate Investing community.
Through using our forums, investors will be able to talk about finance, no down payment purchases, debt payoff, purchase strategies and current real estate news.
Privacy Agreement and Terms of Use. All logos and trademarks in this site are property of their respective owner.
The comments are property of their posters, all the rest 2002 by PropBot.com L.L.C.